Music and running: The science behind it

2007 March 20

Music can also play a vital part in motivating a runner during those long boring runs. Here i have linked the ipod music playlist of Scott Dunlap, an established triathlete and ultra-marathoner. (From his site, i chance upon thousands of runners who have kept blogs on their running and training progress, etc. The Rundown has 23 editions.) The Beats per Minute (BPM) for a song is key in one’s choice, as Intersport advises.

Beats per minute

But how should you decide on which music is good for your next run? It could be helpful to check for the beats per minute (BPM) in a song. The BPM should be identical to your steps per minute – meaning if you have a song with higher BPM you will automatically take more steps per minute. This, however, does not mean that you can only run to fast music.

As an example you can either use music around 170 BPM to 180 BPM, or music that has 85 BPM to 95 BPM. The difference is that you can take one step on each beat of the faster music, where as you can take 2 steps for each beat of the slower music.

In a journal article by Sam Carr, Dave Elliott, Dave Savage in the Journal of Sport Behavior, Vol. 27, 2004, the “Effects of Motivational Music on Work Output and Affective Responses during Sub-Maximal Cycling of a Standardized Perceived Intensity” was examined. It was suggested that affective responses might exert an influence on individuals’ intention to exercise. According to Godin and Shephard (1990) the affective dimension typically refers to individuals’ emotional responses to the thought of adopting behaviors and feelings elicited by the change in behavior (e.g., is the behavior perceived as pleasant/unpleasant or interesting/ boring?). Positive experiences and mindsets yielded positive feelings and a subsequent desire to repeat the behaviour. (Godin, 1994) Therefore, it is important that participation in exercise sessions is a positive experience for individuals (Godin, 1994).

In another sports journal, the Taylor and Francis Journal of Sports Sciences, Volume 17, Number 9/September 1, 1999, “Development and initial validation of an instrument to assess the motivational qualities of music in exercise and sport: The Brunel Music Rating Inventory” shed light on how music does provide much motivation to such individuals with positive and apt mindsets toward sport. The researchers concluded that:

  • Music with clear associations to sport or physical activity may prove motivating (see Karageorghis & Terry, 1997). It should be noted that not all exercise participants are motivated by music that is associated with sport (Priest et al., 2004).
  • Associations that are unrelated to sport or physical activity may also prove motivating. For example, the theme to a popular television adventure series may promote the desire to engage in physical activity. Moreover, lyrics that are related to determination and strength may also conceivably enhance motivation to exercise more intensely and/or for longer.
  • The musical idiom, date of release and artist of the music in question must be allied to the age and sociocultural background of the exercise participants. When a very diverse group is being considered, a systematic attempt must be made to vary these factors (see Priest et al., 2004).
  • When selecting music for a predetermined exercise intensity, music tempo should be linked to exercise heart rate, particularly during high-intensity exercise (see Karageorghis, Jones, & Low, 2006).
  • When selecting music for an individual, the effects of personal associations should be considered. For example, a boxer may have conditioned him or herself by listening to a certain piece of music prior to fighting. Where possible, practitioners should attempt to encourage the formation of such personal associations and harness their power.

Now back to basics, exactly which part of the brain is involved in the recognition of tone and music? Researchers have found out that it is the temporal lobe.

temporal lobe gray

That is why, in severe brain trauma affecting the temporal lobe, there is “decreased recognition of tonal sequeneces and other musical abilities.”

Well then, all these being said, are all these good enough reasons for a Sony S203F mp3 sports walkman?

Or perhaps an Apple ipod and a nike ipod set? After all it is pretty cool.

Well this time i favour Sony. Got it AUD 125 off ebay.com.au.

;)

35 Responses leave one →
  1. 2007 March 20

    thanks for including in grand rounds 3.26. comments are welcome! what are your experiences with regards to music and workout? Any recommended playlist?

  2. 2007 March 21

    I am addicted to music and excercise. I take my MP3 player with me for almost any activity I do. When I am running, I notice that it makes you feel like you are dancing. You keep time to the beat and just kind of dance up the trail. When I am climbing, it helps me focus. I am able to ignore everything else besides the next hold and getting to the top. It also eliminates all those extraneous thoughts and fears of falling or slipping. The focus gives me confidence.

    There are drawbacks however. Music eliminates hearing and therefore you can’t hear the car coming around the blind corner as you are running down a road, or you can’t hear your partner shouting that there is a problem with the rope. So in some ways, it is more risky, but the improved performance is worth the risks.

  3. 2007 March 22

    Flightfire you got it right! There are certainly drawbacks despite its motivational benefits! I haven;t heard of climbers using it though! Isn’t there a much higher risk because you can’t hear any warning signals your belayer or partner wants to tell you?

  4. 2007 March 22

    A wonderful article, Jeffrey. I didn’t know about a lot of that research, but it all makes sense.

    Would you mind if I did a synopsis of your article on my blog and linked to you so more runners could read it? I think they would find it fascinating.

    Thank you for the link to my blog, btw. I’ve had a few dozen readers click through, and they seem to peruse a number of the race write ups and interviews.

    Happy blogging, SD

  5. 2007 March 22

    Hi Scott.

    Not a problem. Glad to do my part to enlighten the running community. I have personally discovered a “renewed fervency” for running recently, and have been surfing around the running blogopshere as well.

    check out my post on that:
    http://jeffreyleow.wordpress.com/2007/03/19/renewed-fervency/

  6. 2007 March 22

    It isn’t just running! I do Jazzercise which is an aerobic dancing/exercise class.
    When we do a routine for a song I love, I can crank up the exertion level and not even feel pain. Discovered that last week with a routine to U2’s “Vertigo”. Amazing!

    And, being a MacAddict, I always go for the iPod…. : )

  7. 2007 March 22

    Ah… Another MacAddict! (warm hand shake)

    This time round i went for Sony despite Parallels not being able to support USB 2.0 and this has given me some unresolved problems. Nevertheless, ths sony s203f is able to play FM radio and that is always a plus. Imagine shaking it thrice and it will change tracks! :) I must say i am more of a tech addict slanting towards mac technology.

    Nonetheless, glad that you are even Jazz-exercising with great music, esp from U2!

  8. 2007 March 23

    I have only used it a couple times when I am climbing and that was mostly for bouldering. I don’t think it would be a huge problem with partner climbing though as a tug on the rope usually signals that something is amiss. The belayer definitely shouldn’t listen to music as you have to pay careful attention in case the leader falls. I can envision a couple bad situations if the leader can’t hear the belayer, but I think most signals travel through the rope. It’s too cold for outdoor climbing right now. I’ll let you know how it works when it warms up a little :)

  9. 2007 March 26

    hey jeff!! i tag! for the very first time :) anw, what you’ve talked about is very true! i can testify from personal experience that running to music improves one’s speed and distance clocked almost immediately :) think it’s the distraction factor more than anything. especially much-loved songs tt you can sing to and later amaze over how you can run and sing and still not be tired!! :) i actually compiled a ‘running songs’ playlist even b4 i read this, and was quite embarrassed that i had to do that to motivate myself to run ;p but now i know everyone’s doing it too!! ;p

  10. 2007 March 26

    hey hey. then u must share your running list with me ya? :) and check out http://www.runstoppable.com

    its great.

  11. 2007 March 29

    There are these great new shorts available for the active iPod user. The shorts have a pocket to hold your iPod and a system to contain the earphone cord. No more annoying cord in your face and catching on everything! You’re free to safely and conveniently live your active lifestyle while listening to your music. Other iPod clothing and accessories available as well.

    Digital Audio Wear

  12. 2007 April 18

    Ah, my kind of post. Thank you for the toughtful insight on a number of potentially unrelated ideas…running cadence, technology, motivation and the temporal lobe!

  13. 2007 April 18

    Thanks a lot. I wanted to sort of integrate these things together and im glad you appreciated it. :)

  14. 2007 September 3
    Fergie permalink

    Hey! This site is really helpful! im doin a science project on if running with music will increase ur speed (on running 400 yards ) compaired to without! dont wrry im giving yall credit!!! U RULE PPL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  15. 2007 September 28

    Very interesting read jeffrey. I had a question on the idea of “music and running”. Do you think that it is possible to speed up or slow down a runners pace by listening to music? Of course you explain that positive music and negative music can effect the outcome of a persons run. More positive music equals a better overall run and workout compared to negative music (less of a performance and workout than that portrayed from the positive music). But, do tempos and rhythms change the pace of a runner? You briefly touch on this subject at the beginning of your paper but I did not really read your results. I am wondering if music were played during track events, whether a runner may be able to increase his or her performance and improve on his or her time based on the type of music (fast or slow) that is playing during his or her run? A faster tempo causing a faster completed race time or a slower tempo causing a slower completed race time.

  16. 2007 December 3

    This is what I like to have this Christmas!

  17. 2007 December 15

    Thanks for sharing this. I am a runner and I do a lot of listening to music when I train on the tracks, road or trail. During the training, I observed that it does a lot of improvement to the result of my time. And this is because of the choices of music i play when I train which is my favorite music. It doesn’t matter if it is fast or slow as long as I like it and does improve my training. and during the race day, I do finish in a best place.

    Kris

  18. 2008 March 10
    ?????? permalink

    Thank You! This REALLY helps with my science project!

  19. 2008 April 16

    You have it so right. There is simply nothing as good as running with music. I think it must be chemical. The experience is just so deep. Amazing. Thanks..

  20. 2008 June 21
    constructive criticism permalink

    excellent source of information…

    but you’d think someone in their third year of med school could properly cite their sources. no? just me?

  21. 2008 September 2
    adrian permalink

    hey jeffery u have quite a good point and it seems u have researched this topic quite well… do you think u could email me and give me a link to some more informaion about this interesting topic as i am doing an experiment on this!!

  22. 2008 September 19
    holly permalink

    is this stuff real? because im doing a science project on it..

  23. 2008 December 1
    Jana permalink

    You are so helpful jeffery! Thanks to you my partners and I were able to finish our project a lot faster!!!!! xoxoxo
    Your the best

  24. 2008 December 4
    Lola permalink

    thanks for the article. I am working on a research paper for a science project, and this helped me a ton!

  25. 2009 February 24
    Lyla permalink

    Hey! I’m doing a research paper, and this is helping me a lot! Thanks!

  26. 2009 August 20

    say, is it really true that cushy running shoes train our feet to land improperly and thus lead to more injuries than running in very thin-soled shoes or barefoot?

  27. 2009 September 12
    Cathal McKillion permalink

    Dont run with music, it only desensitises the run. A bit like wearing a condom during sex. I did an experiement myself in which i ran a 10km race without music and then the following week I ran it along to music. Although I found that running to music was entertaining it took away that buzz you get when i came across the end line. My emotions were much different at the end of the race compared to when i ran without the music. With out the music I was fully engrossed in my runnning, hearing every breath i took and the noises of pain coming from my fellow runners. Hearing these sounds all added to the challenge and the feeling of achievement at the end of the race. On the other hand with the music playing I doddled along in my own little world and crossed the line wondering what all the fuss was about. I’d lost the the feeling of race day, for i had blocked out all the sounds of the reality of the situation with cheesy dance songs. Music and running can be good but running without it will heighten your emotions giving you not only a quicker time but a great sense of achievement. Be strong, drop the tunes and listen to your heart beat instead.

  28. 2009 October 29
    Kyana permalink

    THAT’S WEIRD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ahahahaha!!!
    Bye(:

    • 2009 October 31
      cathal McKillion permalink

      If your not a runner then you wouldnt understand.

  29. 2009 December 12
    Gordon permalink

    Hello, I would check out cadence app , it is an application that makes it easy to find music that matches the beats per minute you run at.

    http://www.cadenceapp.com

    you select the beats per minute that matches your speed, it plays all the music you have that matches that speed.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Blog, MD
  2. Tagged! « monash medical student
  3. so the runner’s high is true after all… « monash medical student
  4. Financial Blog » You can tell a lot about a person…
  5. Music and Running | Turtles Can Run

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS