My role models in the medical arena… (part 1)

2006 December 4
tags:
by Jeffrey

Today we will talk about ROLE MODELS.

Beginnings

I first met mine when he came to my secondary school, Victoria School, to give a talk about pursuing a career in the medical arena during a “Future Careers” seminar. You see, our school was trying to help us choose what kind of courses we would be taking in Junior College, that would be year 11 and 12 for other countries. (Find out more about the Singapore education system.)

At the end of his talk, he mentioned if we wanted a hospital attachment at the end of high school, we could write in to him and request one. That i did, and it indeed helped me gain valuable insight into the medical career.

Wise advice from a respected surgeon

I sought his advice again when i had to choose between my 2 successful applications to study medicine: Bute Medical School, University of St Andrews or Bristol Uni’s medical school. I decided on St Andrews, a 6-year traditional course, for i thought that i could get a better grounding in the basic medical sciences first before embarking on the clinical years at Manchester. Moreover, the uniqueness of the course enabled students to experience the small town of St Andrews in Scotland and the metropolitan city of Manchester was really appealing to me. Hence i chose it, since these were the only 2 offers i had. However, i was also advised that if i got a Monash Uni 5 year course, i should choose it due to the lower cost of tuition fees and living expenses, and its proximity to my homeland Singapore (since it was deemed, with good reason, that the education one receives at either continent will be similar and it was still up to the student to make the most out of his or her own learning experience). God was gracious and Monash Uni offered me a place, so now here i am at Melbourne, studying medicine.

Indeed it was rare to have a senior consultant, former chief of surgery, former chairman of the medical board at a hospital, etc etc, to give you advice over coffee about some low-level stuff like which medical school to choose. At that session, he was patient and comprehensive, making sure i really wanted to do medicine before diving right into further decisions about choosing medical schools. It is a privilege and relationship i treasure till today.

More about Prof Low

I saw him featured in the local newspaper, Today. It reminded me of him once again and i decided to post an article up, as it got me thinking about role models in general, and the art of medicine.

A healer, not just a doctor

This is his profile.

prof low cheng hock

Name : Clin Prof Low Cheng Hock
Designation : Senior Consultant
Credentials : MBBS, M.Med (Surgery), FRACS, FRCS (Edin), FACG, FAMS, PPA(E), PPA(E)
Subspeciality :Upper GI

Source: TTSH Dept of General Surgery

Apart from being a senior consultant at TTSH (he was the ex-surgeon-general / Chief of Surgery there), he is a volunteer consultant to the SAF.

Why he is my role model

Too bad he is retiring soon. My role model, definitely. And its not these long lines of qualifications behind his name, or that he is so distinguished that he is a Justice of Peace in the Republic of Singapore, or that he has reached the top roles in the medical community in Singapore, for example President of the Singapore Medical Council, etc.. It is the way he treats people that matters most.

Before i left for Melbourne to begin my medical studies in Feb 2006, i met up him over lunch, and gave him a book by Harvey White, entitled “Retiring from medicine”, as a thank-you gift for all the advice and help he has rendered ever since i met him. He was rather appreciative and imagine my relief (that i have not bought the wrong and inappropriate gift) during lunch when i probed, “So Prof Low, are you retiring from medicine soon?” “In fact i am! Semi-retiring.” came the immediate frank and cheery reply.

I recall the day he sent a message to my mobile, from Singapore to Melbourne, encouraging and sending his regards, asking me about life in medical school. We also correspond through email and meet up from time to time in Singapore. I remember the time i was back for my first 1-month holiday in Singapore and i reflected on my 1st semester in Monash Medicine, telling him how my peers seemed to be so set on the specialty they will embark on in the future, or how they want to reach “consultant level” in the shortest number of years possible, and Prof Low told me (not in exact words),

“When you eventually become a specialist, nobody is going to ask you how many years you took to specialise… What matters most is the patient. Moreover, in those years that you are specialising and doing further training in your medical career, it is the time you start working, earning cash, living your life, perhaps starting a family. Do keep these things in perspective.”

If i, a lowly medical student, am treated like this by him, what more his family members, or close friends, or colleagues? Every doctor i have met during the hospital attachment uses adjectives like “nice”, “warm”, “esteemed”, “well-respected”, to describe him. The nurses and even the receptionists know him and speak of him cheerfully.

The importance of finding and having role models

Its amazing how big a part a certain role model can play in one’s life. And in my case, in my future career as a doctor. Role models are definitely important and it is crucial to find one.

One whom can guide you and prod you along the long and arduous path, one who can encourage you along the way should you get disillusioned, one to turn to when making important life-changing or major decisions, one whom you can look up to, saying “hey when i grow up i want to be like him/her!” or “hey, this is the kind of (profession) i have always aspired or dreamed about becoming!”, or one that perhaps would like you to become what they never became…

“Better than me”

In this case, Prof Low mentions that he wants his students to be BETTER than him. That kind of spirit is excellent. You will know that he definitely wants to and will teach you all he can, to impart what others before him has passed down to him. Will all teachers or seniors be like that?

The art of medicine

Moving on to another point, the article mentions that Prof Low is a healer, not just a doctor.

“I spend a lot of time with patients, listening to them. A good communication process can help you make a diagnosis more than half the time…. Practising medicine is not as straight-forward as one thinks. Sometimes our perception of our rules, our beliefs, our morals, have come into play. Ultimately, patients come first – whatever you do must be for the good of the patient, not your own benefit.”

Will we aspire to be a doctor like that? Or will we perhaps be tempted or be forced by circumstances to “go in, fix it and get out”, as thehelix mentions in this post.

A blogger shares this about a certain Dr. Frank.

The point is a doctor named Frank Coleman, a diminutive man who is a giant of a compassionate human being. Frank knows his medicine. Oh, he is a superb physican. More important, he also knows each of the people he treats, and he treats them as sacred individuals. Frank is not one of those production line “a patient every fifteen minute” physicians. He is a healer, not just a doctor. He treats the whole person, not the malady. He is a listener. He holds your hand, touches your soul. He has a soothing and reassuring aura about him. He puts you at ease. He has a laying on of presence. It’s hard to be anxious and scared when he is with you. He makes you feel comfortable in the usually awkward, nervous, and often intimidating and frightening environment of an examining or hospital room. It is easy to see him as a human being, not just as a doctor costumed in a white coat because he sees you as a human being. He converses with you, notices you. He doesn’t merely examine your body; he treats your spirit as well. You are to him a fellow human being rather than just a patient. He makes the time to take time with you. There were no barriers between him and the other person in the room. There never is a harsh, cold, clinical distance when he was in the room. You know he wants to be there and is not in a rush to be somewhere else. You know he cares, deeply cares. He wants to help. His very presence tells you, “It will be okay.” You know you are safe in his hands. He was our family physician until he closed his private practice; he saved my Susan’s life a few decades ago.

Darn, i sure want to be a doctor like that. Wouldn’t you as a medical student want to aspire to be a doctor as described? More importantly, wouldn’t you as a patient want your doctor to be like that?

The Victorian Spirit lives on…

It is even more amazing if your role model was educated in the same instituition as you, or somehow has something similar as you. Perhaps he/she went to the same medical school as you. Perhaps he/she went through the same residency programme as you.

As for me, i’m proud to associate with Prof Low. He went to the same high school as me. And that would be Victoria School, Singapore. (forgive me for this little last bit of “patriotism” to my alma mater, it would be sad if you personally didn’t have a little in you)

For others came before and went,
And carried to the world,
Victoria’s fame and our intent
To keep her flag unfurled.

Victoria School Badge
- Last stanza of the Victoria School Anthem

Oh and hey, look out for part 2 of “my role models in the medical arena…”, where i will be talking about Dr SH Tow, former Chair of Obgyn at KK Hospital, Singapore, current senior pastor of Calvary Bible-Presbyterian Church, Singapore.

20 Responses leave one →
  1. 2007 January 9

    Hey Jeffrey!
    humble, compassionate and ‘genius’ may be words soon to follow your name in this brand new line of life. Followed your recommended links to here. Awesome stuff mate.

    hp

  2. 2007 January 9

    hi there. you are?

  3. 2007 January 9

    where did u link from? science roll?

  4. 2007 January 11

    Hey Jeffrey,
    It’s Hiep, monash med with you. Followed your links from muso, where you recommended blogborygmi – im hooked!
    Hope your holidays have been, and will be, satisfying with a dash of adventure, comfort and family.
    Cheers
    Hiep

  5. 2007 January 11
    jeff permalink

    hi.
    wow. yea/ get onto med bloggin!

  6. 2007 March 27
    kabababrubarta permalink

    Nice site! kabababrubarta

  7. 2008 August 1
    Adrian permalink

    Hi there! I’m a prospective medical student who’s torn between the UK and Aussie medical schools too. My situation is quite different, though. I’ve got three offers from the UK medical schools(Bristol, Nottingham and Leeds)to read Medicine and another one from Monash University, Malaysian Campus. So..if you were me, which one would you choose and why? I’m attracted by Monash Malaysia’s low cost course in comparison to the UK medical schools’.

    I don’t know if i’ve missed out something but you didn’t seem to tell us the reason you chose Monash over St.Andrews.

    I had a nice time reading your article. Thanks a bunch!

  8. 2008 August 3

    i would choose one of the UK schools, and particularly nottingham becos’ firstly, monash malaysia is only recognised by AMC. it is not recognised by Singapore Medical Council. the clinical years will be spent in hospitals in JB, Malaysia and it is starkly different to that in metropolitan Australia. The consultants will be of different standards and it is clear that the Malaysian health care system is nowhere near compared to that of Aust. many of the best specialists are in private practice.

    nottingham is great becos in 5 years, u get MBBS PLUS a BMedSci. That is fantastic.

  9. 2008 September 12
    Malaysian permalink

    Dear Jeffrey,

    Have you ever set foot in any Malaysian health care centre at all? On what grounds can you say that the consultants in Malaysia are of different standards as compared to Australia? I get the impression that you think Malaysia is some backward country with sub-standard healthcare and even the consultants are inferior to those in Australia. This is the mentality of the many Singaporeans I have encountered. However, I think you, and many of your friends, have never had any experience with Malaysian doctors, hospitals, or even a clinic of any kind. Therefore, I don’t think you are in any position to judge the Malaysian healthcare system and its consultants. “Many of the best specialists are in private practice”, you say. Is this based on any solid facts you have obtained, or is it merely hearsay? The students in Monash Malaysia are probably getting alot more clinical experience in the JB hospital than some of the students in Australia, please ask the 5th years who have had rotations at the hospital. I can assure you our Malaysian consultants are in no way inferior to those in Australia. Many of the teaching doctors I have come across are everything we could have hoped for, and more. Kindly seek information from your friends in Malaysia before making such statements belittling the healthcare system and even the doctors that you do not have the slightest idea about. Even if it is your personal opinion, your readers still have the right to get an opinion that has factual basis.

  10. 2008 September 12

    firstly, i did answer adrian’s question because he was asking between UK medical schools and Monash University, Malaysian Campus. he mentioned he was ” attracted by Monash Malaysia’s low cost course in comparison to the UK medical schools”. so hence i brought in the topic of monash malaysia.

    secondly, i apologise for grossly misrepresenting monash malaysia. i am sure the AMC has good grounds for recognizing them as an accredited school.

    however, that said, AMC’s accreditation does not change what many students here in Monash Clayton think about this new medical school in Malaysia. to put it the way *I* put it is, to say the least, extremely mild. i merely said…

    1. “the clinical years will be spent in hospitals in JB, Malaysia and it is starkly different to that in metropolitan Australia.” — this is a fact that cannot be changed. the education received is clearly **different**. how different? better or worse? i cannot say having not experienced both, neither can you, because you haven’t experienced metropolitan Australia’s hospitals. but it surely will be “starkly different”, in terms of the demographics of patients seen, the tropical diseases, etc.

    2. “The consultants will be of different standards.” — well maybe i was wrong in saying the consultants in malaysia are of different standards. they may be equally qualified from boards in the UK. this is probably just my bias. but i stand to be corrected that the best specialists are not in the public system. it was mentioned to us in preclinical years of malaysia’s healthcare system’s many problems. to add, “different standards” still apply even if they are similarly accredited with a FRCP/S.

    3. “and it is clear that the Malaysian health care system is nowhere near compared to that of Aust” — well, if you think i can’t compare this, maybe you should ask the World Health Organisation. (http://www.photius.com/rankings/healthranks.html) Australia is ranked 32nd. Malaysia? 49th. am i wrong in saying it is nowhere near? that’s probably a bit harsh, but surely it is NOT near. just compare accessibility and affordability. you for one will know australia would not be so low in the rankings if not for the aboriginal populations, which drags down Aust each year. and yes, i do think singapore’s healthcare system is better (6th).

    FINALLY, i’m sorry if you have felt insulted with my comments. i may have misrepresented malaysia and monash malaysia in some ways. for that i apologise.

    but do know that many students here in melbourne (esp international students who pay much more than you guys over in malaysia) do not think very highly of the course over there. it may be because of how new it is, etc. whatever reasons they are, it does not change how we view another course. it is great that you are defending it and providing an update of how good a clinical education you are receiving. good for you.

  11. 2008 September 12
    Josh permalink

    the rankings from 2000?

    Jeff why are u such a bigot? hah. It’s easy to run a small healthcare system in a fully-metropolitan country; at least when compared to running one in a country of majority land area being desert or in a place where corruption is infamously rampant.

    let it go mate! (as it goes back home, ‘u know i know can already’)

  12. 2008 September 12

    im actually not so much for the point singapore’s healthcare system is better. im more on the point that the education one receives at monash malaysia is different from that the mainstream receive at melbourne. that’s all.

  13. 2008 September 12
    Josh permalink

    hooo-kay! agreed of course, every course, clinical site, consultant’s method is unique/special/has pros n cons;

    i got more to bitch to u abt, maybe when we meet up or online. cheers.

  14. 2008 September 18

    I’m afraid you were being a bit presumptive there, and I admit being not very impressed. It is very difficult to quantify the quality of one’s education without acutually experiencing it by himself. Quantifying qualiy? Now that’s comedy.

  15. 2008 September 18

    But that being said, I do have reservations about the “Monash the business entity”, not “Monash the medical education provider “. It’s motives in Malaysia are dubious at best, as with the other universities setting up outposts in SEA. Keep up your good work jeff!

  16. 2008 September 18

    yea my bad in those comments.

    did you know monash is setting up some branch of med sch in qatar or sth ? one of those middle eastern countries! gee.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Personal update « monash medical student
  2. monash interview tips « monash medical student
  3. Gen Surg Clinics « monash medical student

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS